Skip to main content

tv   Hardball With Chris Matthews  MSNBC  January 2, 2012 7:00pm-8:00pm EST

7:00 pm
they'll throw a temper tantrum before admitting he raised taxes and was willing to compromise. we must realize that those that are running now are not even in the tradition of their own party. thanks for watching. i'm al sharpton. but, first, "hardball" starts right now. giving newt the boot! let's play "hardball." i'm chris matthews, the best place to be for the iowa caucuses. java joe's in downtown des moines. we've got one day to go and a rapidly changing race and no one is confident enough about who's going to win to make firm predictions.
7:01 pm
leading off tonight, the politics of destruction. mitt romney has swooped into iowa, essentially at the last minute, and destroyed newt gingrich. on the stump, romney floats above it all, reciting america the beautiful, and pretending to remain positive, but his doctor jekyll and mr. hyde campaign has flooded the airways with a sewer full of negative ads that have been dumped on newt. you can't turn on a tv here without seeing newt destroyed. beat the only guy who can beat you, that's romney's strategy, and that's our top story. also, donald trump had his moment, so did michele bachmann, rick perry, herman cain, newt gingrich, and ron paul. and now it's rick santorum's turn, and just at the right time. three recent polls have all said the same thing. romney's on top, paul has
7:02 pm
stalled, and santorum is surging, and most important, perhaps, if you're romney, gingrich is toast. and isn't that just what mitt romney ordered? plus, mitt happens historically. if republicans lose a presidential race with a moderate like john mccain, they come back with a conservative. but the republican right is terrified its support divided among so many conservatives the moderate mitt romney could sneak in the back door and win the nomination. and while no one was looking, president obama's surrogates out here have slipped into iowa and begun hitting romney in ways that his republican opponents haven't. it's pretty clear who team obama thinks is going to be the nominee. finally, let me finish with the victory of dollars over democracy. i've got some great people with us, all msnbc political analysts. howard fineman is "the huffington post" media group editorial director. eugene robinson is a "washington post" columnist, pulitzer prize winner, and michael steele is the former chairman of the republican national committee. yesterday at a gingrich event in marshalltown, iowa, gingrich said he'd been romney voted. so i asked the former speaker if this is the future of american politics. the loy rhetoric on the trail by the candidate himself, meanwhile the nasty super pac anonymous ads from a front
7:03 pm
group. here's our exchange? >> no, no more than it has been in the past. >> but you've won all these debates, and you come in here, and all i watch on television are these restore our future ads, they're legal now, with no, i paid for that ad by mitt romney, and they go out, and he has a beautiful family, but his ads are trash, trashing you constantly. >> he is assuming american people are stupid. i don't think the american people are stupid. >> but the polls show they're responding. the polls are reacting to this. >> i'm sure within a few weeks, every american will know this is his pac. >> he took you from the 30s down to the teens. it's working. why doesn't he do it in 50 states? >> all it did was guarantee that some other conservative emerged, and didn't help romney at all. >> but he's not afraid of the other conservative, he got rid
7:04 pm
of you. >> he just slowed me down. >> what stops him from doing this in any other state? >> you just have to list his former staff and his donors and he can go around the country all he wants to. here's may tag line. somebody who will lie to you to get to be president will lie to you when they are president. >> but you don't have any problems with citizens united, these big donors spending tons of money for anonymous ads attacking you. >> first of all, no ads are attacking anybody. >> but his are. >> second, my solution would be to eliminate all the election laws and allow people to give unlimited personal money, after tax, and file every night and let the candidates run the campaigns and have the candidate be responsible. i think the current mess is a disgrace.
7:05 pm
i think it debilitates politics. i think it strengthens millionaires. and it weakens middle class candidates. >> isn't that amazing, gene robinson? there is a conservative republican saying, this anything-goes campaigning, where citizens united rule that a guy with lots of money, the koch brothers or who else can spend zillions of dollars without putting their name on the ad. it's not like little league where you put the name on the back. and he's destroying newt. >> we need some regulation, so these millionaires don't take over! it's an amazing thing. >> and now here he is, the guy hosted on his own petard. they say things like corporations are people too, and dollars are votes. now he turns on the team, poor him and calista. it's sewage coming out of the tv set, constantly. he can give a million debate
7:06 pm
performances. and romney out there with his beautiful family reciting "american the beautiful." it's like that scene in "the godfather." do you remember? crying at the opera. >> romney's out there with the flags waving -- >> "america the beautiful." >> meanwhile, mitt romney's saying, i can't do modern politics. >> here it is. here's romney. this is a scene out of "the godfather." remember that scene? anyway, let's watch him. just a few days ago. let's watch. >> i love the words of that -- that national hymn, if you will, "oh, beautiful forespacious skies, for amber waves of grain," do corn fields paint for amber waves of grain? the songwriter said this, "oh, beautiful, for patriot dream
7:07 pm
that seized beyond the years." >> okay, isn't that beautiful? >> michael steele, former chair of the republican national committee. there you have the perfect reason why people don't like politicians. an absolute bogus fraud show. there's the guy looking like a million bucks, praising america, while the sewage pours out of the tv set. your thoughts? >> am i supposed to be upset about that? >> i thought you might have a conscious. >> i do. it struck me, it's interesting, the tone that romney has taken in the last few days of this campaign, vis-a-vis newt, has been much more conciliatory, much more what he's saying. what his folks are doing is very different --
7:08 pm
>> let's watch what his folks doing. >> here's my point. he reminds me of the good samaritan who comes and helps the guy up off the ground, but doesn't tell you, the people who beat you up are my guys. >> here he is, the pro-romney super pac, "restore our future," which has nothing to do with mitt romney, of course, hammering gingrich with negative advertising. here's a piece of it. >> barack obama's plan is working. destroy mitt romney, run against newt gingrich. newt has a ton of baggage. he was fined $300,000 for ethics violations and took $1.6 million from freddie mac before it helped cause the economic meltdown. newt supports amnesty for illegal immigrants and teamed with nancy pelosi and al gore on global warming. maybe that's why george will calls him the least conservative candidate. check the facts at newtfacts.com. restore our future inc. is responsible for the content of this message. >> here's another one. let's watch the second one. this is along the same line, michael steele. this is what you call the good samaritan, here he is, another pro-romney group, the same one, by the restore our future, while destroying mitt romney -- i'm sorry. newt gingrich. let's listen. >> oops!
7:09 pm
>> every notice how some people make a lot of mistakes? >> it was probably a mistake. >> i made a mistake. >> i've made mistakes at times. >> so far, newt gingrich has admitted his mistakes or flipped on teaming up with nancy pelosi, immigration, medicare, health care, iraq, attacking mitt romney and more. >> i made a big mistake in the spring. >> haven't we had enough mistakes? restore our future is responsible for the content of this message. >> restore our future. they never say the word mitt romney, even though all his people and donors are involved in it. you're shaking your head? >> i agree with you. here's one reason why it's working here. first of all, the sheer tonnage. i've never seen in a concentrated space so much advertising, you know, from davenport all the way out to sioux city and back -- >> you can't escape it. >> you can't escape it. you can watch "entertainment tonight," you can choose anything -- >> the other thing here, newt is
7:10 pm
to some extent made vulnerable by the way he rose to prominentsy. >> how so? >> because he did in the debates. he didn't spend a year and a half here in iowa, becoming an iowan. rick santorum has essentially become an iowa. he speaks to iowa from the inside out. people know who he is, they know his record, they know what he stands for. the other reason this kind of advertising works is that most people here in iowa didn't really know anything very much about newt gingrich, so this negative advertising is painting on a blank canvas. of a famous guy who is a blank campus. >> except there's a john henry aspect to this. newt gingrich earned that positive number he came in here with by live debate performances. >> right, on his own. >> he didn't do it by going from town to town. >> but he performed in the debates. look, newt gingrich knows a lot about policy, about domestic and foreign policy. >> but iowans didn't know a lot about him. >> wait a minute. i'll take that up to a point. you cannot sit there and think that the folks of iowa were totally clueless about his tenure as speaker of the house. his -- his takeover of the conservative movement and moving it into the prominence of 1994, with the historic election. so you can't paint this brush that the people here in this state had no clue who newt gingrich was. they did. they had it in context. what these ads did was take it out of context. and that's the point of negative advertising, is to take you out
7:11 pm
of context -- but is it legitimate, necessarily? >> my sense is that all the negative ads are working. that people i'm talking to -- >> yeah, they're working. >> -- are aware about what's in all the negative ads, and they can recite all the reasons from the ads why not to vote for this candidate, not to vote for that candidate. >> that's why -- >> voting out there turned off all the candidates, so libertarians will vote for ron paul. they would have done it 400 years ago. the christian conservatives will probably go to santorum. what happens the rest, we don't know. here's gingrich lining up his attack for new hampshire. here he is going to new hampshire with this catch this line of attack. he ain't defenseless. let's watch. >> i think new hampshire is the perfect state to have a debate over romney care and to have a debate about tax-paid abortions, which see signed, and to have a
7:12 pm
debate about putting planned parenthood on a government board, which he signed, and to have a debate about appointing liberal judges, which he did. so i think new hampshire is a good place to start the debate for south carolina. >> well, you know, it's one of those battles in spartacus, each guy has his own weapon. he'll go out there to new hampshire to propel himself into south carolina. how can you vote for romney if he signed a pro-abortion funding bill? >> new hampshire's all about south carolina for newt. and that's his staging ground t sweep into the south, pick up what he can there, move into florida, and leave romney battered, bruised on those issues that matter to the core
7:13 pm
of our party. >> gene? >> and what we know about newt gingrich is, you know, if he's wounded, you've got to kill him. >> has he killed him? >> no. and i think newt is going to continue. because he believes that indefatigability is the key to success. >> also, he's a fighter. and he actually fights better from behind than ahead. that's the why he is, mentally. the other thing is, he's got the manchester "union leader" in new hampshire, which endorsed him. now, the "union leader" doesn't have quite the power it did a decade ago, but -- >> will they jump in on this on his side? >> there's no big sport among conservatives in new hampshire, no more fun they can have than attacking mitt romney. they've been doing it for years and years and years. joe mcquaid, will go nuts on newt's behalf. >> let's start with the former
7:14 pm
republican leader. okay, let me ask you this, who's going to be mitt romney's biggest opponent two, three weeks from now? will it be santorum, who's doing very well here and may win tomorrow night, or will it be newt gingrich, who will still be in the fight? >> i think it will be newt. >> still biggest threat down the road. >> i think more likely to be newt. >> newt's better copy. it's that simple. he's better copy. >> i think it's newt. anyone, gene robinson, michael steele, and howard fineman are staying with us. could santorum end up the winner here tomorrow night? that's ahead here on "hardball" at java joe's. when bp made a commitment to the gulf,
7:15 pm
we knew it would take time, but we were determined to see it through. today, while our work continues, i want to update you on the progress: bp has set aside 20 billion dollars to fund economic and environmental recovery. we're paying for all spill- related clean-up costs. and we've established a 500 million dollar fund so independent scientists can study the gulf's wildlife and environment for ten years. thousands of environmental samples from across the gulf have been analyzed by independent labs under the direction of the us coast guard. i'm glad to report all beaches and waters are open for everyone to enjoy. and the economy is showing progress with many areas on the gulf coast having their best tourism seasons in years. i was born here, i'm still here and so is bp. we're committed to the gulf for everyone who loves it, and everyone who calls it home.
7:16 pm
c'mon, michael! get in the game! [ male announcer ] don't have the hops for hoops with your buddies? lost your appetite for romance? and your mood is on its way down. you might not just be getting older. you might have a treatable condition called low testosterone or low t. millions of men, forty-five or older, may have low t. so talk to your doctor about low t. hey, michael! [ male announcer ] and step out of the shadows. hi! how are you? [ male announcer ] learn more at isitlowt.com. [ laughs ] hey! hi! how are you? ♪ more and more folks are trying out snapshot from progressive. a totally different way to save on car insurance. the better you drive, the more you can save. no wonder snapshot's catching on. plug into the savings you deserve with snapshot from progressive.
7:17 pm
you tell us what you want to pay, and we give you a range of coverages to choose from. who is she? that's flobot. she's this new robot we're trying out, mostly for, like, small stuff. wow! look at her go! she's pretty good. she's pretty good. hey, flobot, great job. oops. [ powers down ] uh-oh, flobot is broken. the "name your price" tool, only from progressive. call or click today. welcome back to "hardball." well, all the polls coming out of iowa show one thing. rick santorum has the momentum. "the des moines register" poll has romney with a narrow lead. romney at 24%. ron paul's at 22. and rick santorum's in third with 15. but don't go by that. you also got newt gingrich, rick perry, and rick perry trailing the field. but when you look at just the last two days of the polling, here's what's interesting.
7:18 pm
santorum rockets up to second place to 21, all the way from 15 to 21 in a matter of four days, leapfrogging ron paul. we're book with our panel of msnbc political analysts, howard fineman of "the huffington post," eugene robinson of "the washington post," and michael steele, former chairman of the national republican committee. let's play pundit now, pure pundit, without any attitude. which is just picking this thing. what do you see in the numbers, howard? >> what i see in the numbers is santorum coming on strong, ron paul having a lot of enthusiasm out there, and mitt romney trying to hang on, having allowed expectations to get a little bit out of hand here.
7:19 pm
now he needs a win. and i think it's going to be very close, down to the wire. but the two have the energy, the genuine energy and the genuine momentum are santorum and paul. >> gene? >> i see the santorum surge. i think he's peaking at the right time. the numbers also show that iz supporters are more likely -- say they're more likely to actually go out and caucus tomorrow than romney's do. >> yeah, 76% say they're actually going to -- and this is cold weather out here, like it is in a lot of places. windy too. very windy. does the bad weather affect iowans. >> this is nothing. this is warm. this is warm. >> this is warm. >> well, it's not warm, but not that bad. but i see santorum. >> what do you think, mike? >> i think the trend lines are certainly there for santorum. i think the numbers, the 56% voter turnout, enthusiasm for a ron paul is understated.
7:20 pm
i think it's closer to the 76% -- >> i agree. >> but longer term. i think this is an opportunity coming out of iowa where the conservatives of the party say maybe santorum is the guy that we can begin to coalesce behind. maybe he's the one who can the meddle to go the distance. and that's going to be an interesting, i think, one-week transition between here and iowa to see -- >> huckabee won this last time with 24%. could that happen again? >> yes, it could happen. and don't forget about yet. yesterday all the power pastors were out. and santorum has worked them to a fairtheewell. santorum has them, they're coalescing, and santorum has a lot of former huckabee people in his campaign, both in his inner staff and in what i call the power pastors in the state, all the way out in sioux city. >> do they name names? >> they don't do it from the pulpit. you don't do it from the pulpit, although some pastors think you should do it. they basically don't do it. but they have huge networks. they've got congregations of 1,000, 1,500. they put out the word. these people are active in politics.
7:21 pm
they're almost like the guys back in philly, chris, except they've got their precincts and their precincts are their parishioners. >> i heard the message at church yesterday out here, the catholic church out here, the bishop was talking about voting your values. >> the catholics are going with santorum. >> and those values voters are really attracted to santorum. that's one reason, i think, he's going to do so well. but i think newt gingrich is likely to come out of iowa with enough support left to contest santorum for that coalescing conservative bloc, if indeed it coalesces. >> let's take a look at santorum. here he is going after mitt romney on what romney considers his biggest strength. his business background. let's listen. >> we are not looking for a chief executive officer for this country. we're looking for a commander in chief. we're looking for someone who has experience, someone who can lead, someone who can lead our military, but also someone who can lead in convincing the american public and the congress to do the things that are necessary to transform this country, and that's not what
7:22 pm
ceos do. ceos assign people who work for them. >> okay. and getting back at him, here's romney who kept his criticism trained on president obama, but yesterday he took this delicate swipe, almost patty cake at santorum and gingrich. let's listen to what he said. >> senator santorum was kind enough to endorse me last time around. i appreciate that. and we've been friends. i can tell you that our backgrounds are quite different. lightning speaker gingrich, senator santorum has spent his career in government, in washington. nothing wrong with that, but it's a very different background than i have. >> that is patty cake, michael steele. does he want to keep santorum in this race? >> absolutely. >> because he can beat him later? >> yeah, that's the goal. that's a very good analogy. because santorum helps do a number of things. one, it gives the conservatives someone else to look at while they still may play a little bit with newt and perry.
7:23 pm
so you're keeping that division within the rank and file. i said to michele bachmann early this morning, i said, if you guy have ever thought about having a meeting where, you pick one of us and -- >> who chairs that meeting? >> what'd she say? >> well, she said no. but maybe they should. >> howard? >> i've got to say, my first reaction to the santorum video that you just showed is that he's lost every iowa state graduate in the -- he was wearing a university of iowa jersey. >> okay. here's mitt romney took a shot at president obama with a pop culture reference. by the way, it's about the
7:24 pm
kardashians. he may have written the line an lucille ball, maybe, one in a thousand chances. one in a million chances he wrote this about kardashian. let's listen. >> i've been looking at some video clips on youtube of president obama, then candidate obama, going through iowa, making promises. and i think the gap between his promises and his performance is the largest i've seen, well, since the kardashian wedding and the promise of 'til death do we part. >> romney, i don't think so. >> if you lined up the three kardashian sisters in front of him, he could not tell them apart. i'd be willing to bet -- what's his -- $10,000, how about that? >> who writes this stuff? it isn't him. >> is he trying to be too cool? >> did he also compare the president to lucy and the chocolate factory -- >> they compared newt gingrich to that. >> so he compares obama to marie antoinette, he compares newt gingrich to lucy ricardo, and he compares his enemies to the kardashians. i guarantee you, it's not
7:25 pm
accidental. >> all women. >> not accidental. >> what do you think he's up to here. >> it's the this, it's the, you know, the culture war translated through the lens of mitt romney. >> so it separates you, howard fineman, from the average pundit, is the ability to step back and see the common patterns of evil. >> i'm just telling you -- >> to see the malevolent -- >> i'm not saying it's malevolence, it's a strategy. >> that's why you're the best. eugene robinson, sir, you animal have a pulitzer prize. >> and i just have the suit. >> still ahead, mitt romney has a path to victory, that means republicans may elect another moderate to president, something that terrifies the right wing. you're watching "hardball" a lot java joes in des moines on the eve of the caucuses, only on msnbc. [ male announcer ] cranberry juice? wake up!
7:26 pm
♪ that's good morning, veggie style. hmmm [ male announcer ] for half the calories -- plus veggie nutrition. could've had a v8. ♪ home was an airport lounge and an ipad ♪ ♪ made sure his credit score did not go bad ♪ ♪ with a free-credit-score-dot-com ♪ ♪ app that he had ♪ downloaded it in the himalayas ♪ ♪ while meditating like a true playa ♪ ♪ now when he's surfing down in chile'a ♪ ♪ he can see when his score is in danger ♪ ♪ if you're a mobile type on the go ♪ ♪ i suggest you take a tip from my bro ♪ ♪ and download the app that lets you know ♪ ♪ at free-credit-score-dot-com now let's go. ♪ vo: offer applies with enrollment in freecreditscore.com™.
7:27 pm
7:28 pm
♪ ooh baby, (what) can i do for you today? ♪ [ female announcer ] need help keeping your digestive balance? align can help. only align has bifantis, a patented probiotic that naturally helps maintain your digestive balance. try align to help retain a balanced digestive system. try the #1 gastroenterologist recommended probiotic. align. so we're out here in the iowa caucuses at java joe's, one of the neatest restaurants in the world.
7:29 pm
how many of you come here regularly? and how many come here for "hardball"? that's what i like. let me ask you, are you voting in the caucuses? >> yes. >> who are you going to vote for? >> mitt romney. >> all right. why? >> i really like his policies. >> are you a moderate, conservative, right of center, where are you? >> moderate. >> that makes sense. >> he won't say that. you will. >> i'm voting for democrats. >> democrats. >> obama, all the way. >> obama. >> obama. i'm afraid this would happen. it's breaking my heart.
7:30 pm
>> obama. >> don't go breaking my heart. >> obama. >> obama. >> see, this is what i -- anybody here voting republican this year? we got one. we got a live one here. who you voting for? >> mitt romney. >> why? what's your reasons? >> i like his policies. >> how would you describe yourself? right of center, right wing, far right, somewhere near the middle, moderate? >> moderate. >> is mitt romney a moderate? >> tends to be, somewhat. >> is he willing to admit it? >> maybe, i hope. >> how come the other day when i asked if he could say, let them eat cake, i said, can you say that in french, governor, he said, yes, but i won't. why do you think he's afraid to speak french in understand. >> probably because he knows we won't understand what he's saying. >> why won't mitt romney speak french? >> because he doesn't want to speak too french. >> but if he doesn't speak french, does that means he's elitist? >> he thinks so. >> so he's speaking down to iowans. >> he needs the perfect amount of scuff on his shoes for us. >> des moines is a french state. >> i love it! >> what'd you just say? >> i said des moines is a french
7:31 pm
name. >> so if he pronounces it demwois? >> loud as you can yell, democrat or republican, who's going to win the caucuses tomorrow night? one, two, three. >> everybody who thinks it's romney, yell it now? >> romney! >> everybody who thinks it's bachmann. yell all together. all the people who think it's going to be huntsman tomorrow. one, two, three. everybody who thinks it's going to be gingrich tomorrow. one, two, three. everybody who thinks it's going to be ron paul tomorrow, one, two, three. >> ron paul! >> ron paul! >> everybody who thinks it's going to be santorum tomorrow, one, two, three. >> santorum! santorum! >> romney just won this thing. romney has just won the java joe's caucus. we'll be right back with more "hardball."
7:32 pm
oh just return it. returning gifts is easier than ever with priority mail flat rate boxes from the postal service. if it fits, it ships anywhere in the country for a low flat rate. plus i can pick it up for free. perfect because we have to get that outta this house. c'mon, it's not that... gahh, oh yeah that's gotta go... priority mail flat rate shipping starts at just $4.95. only from the postal service. a simpler way to ship and return. if you took the top down on a crossover? if there were buttons for this? wouldn't it be cool if your car could handle the kids... ♪ ...and the nurburgring? or what if you built a car in tennessee that could change the world? yeah, that would be cool. nissan. innovation for today. innovation for tomorrow. innovation for all. ♪ i wish my patients could see what i see. ♪ that over time,
7:33 pm
having high cholesterol plus diabetes... or high blood pressure... or family history of early heart disease... can put them at increased risk for plaque buildup. and they'd see that it's more important to get their cholesterol where their doctor wants. and why for these patients, when diet and exercise alone aren't enough, i prescribe crestor. adding crestor lowers bad cholesterol by up to 52%. and is also proven to slow plaque buildup. [ female announcer ] crestor is not right for everyone. like people with liver disease... or women who are nursing, pregnant, or may become pregnant. simple blood tests will check for liver problems. tell your doctor about other medicines you're taking. or if you have muscle pain or weakness. that could be a sign of a rare but serious side effect. is your cholesterol where your doctor wants? ask your doctor if crestor is right for you. [ female announcer ] if you can't afford your medication, astra zeneca may be able to help.
7:34 pm
7:35 pm
a body found in mt. raineer shooting suspect was located and identified. he's a sus is spekt also in an earlier shooting that left four people wounded. two peps were found with his body. a man believed to be responsible for dozens of arson fires represents a person of interest caught on video. they have caused property damage. iran successfully test fires long-range missiles.
7:36 pm
the u.s. fleet says it will not allow shipments to be disrupted. now back to "hardball." welcome back to "hardball." according to polls, on the eve of the iowa caucus, 25% support, kompb conservatives say the problem for that is they can't agree on who the alternative is. the result could be mitt romney sneaking through the pack and eking out a win. for some conservatives, that prospect reminds them of john mccain back in 2008, the moderate senator, who never won the love of the conservative base. could it happen two election cycles in a row? joe klein's a "time" magazine
7:37 pm
columnist and jonathan martin is senior political reporter for politico. john, you start here. usually parties correct themselves. they run a pragmatist, that doesn't work, the next time they run somebody with deep conviction. it looks like romney is still the favorite right now to follow john mccain, someone in the senator. >> that's why you see so many unhappy republicans these days. that's why the crowds are low this time, that's why the turnout may be lower than last time.
7:38 pm
because republicans are simply not excited by this field. now, romney and mccain are two different as moderates as moderates can be. romney's a corporate moderate and mccain was an immoderate moderate. a man of passion. >> a maverick. the question you have to ask, jonathan, is this question. who's a problem for them? mccain's problem was he couldn't beat obama. but everybody thinks romney could be a pretty good opponent for obama. he would definitely fill in a lot of that center vote. >> and chris, if you talk to iowans, you hear the same response about romney. it's not because he stirs some deep passion in them about storming the barricades. it's because he's seen as the guy that can beat the president they despise. >> did you hear these two people back here. i said, why do you like romney, he said, because they're a moderate. the old line was given by marie antoinette.
7:39 pm
let's watch. >> did you say, let them eat cake in french? >> i can but i won't. >> we're in des moines. it's a town named by the french. >> but he's just a man of the soil and not a very sophisticated guy. >> i look at these numbers out here like we've all done now. this is so ironic. here's a party that's largely conservative, the republican party. it's deeply conservative. 75% of the people relentlessly say, not to mitt. in the latest polling, he's only up to 23. it's almost like that roulette weal in ""casablanca." >> there's only one of him and there are like five of them. and that's what's helping him. the other thing that's helping him is the, oh, okay, factor. you hear it all the time. people have dated newt, they've
7:40 pm
dated santorum a little bit. they've dated michelle, and they say, okay, okay, he's the guy who looks like a president. we'll go with him. remember, this is the republican party where there's a genetic predisposition to go with the guy who seems like the most likely president. >> and chris, there's not a goldwater, there's not a reagan. there's no galvanizing figure on the right who is bringing folks away from the rockefeller or the bush $41. there are a handful of conservatives, none of which have really sort of captivated the imagination of the party's conservative base. santorum was the closest thing to that. >> i don't know why they're not willing to outsource their nomination. yesterday, newt gingrich made the point that support for conservative candidates was much higher than for the moderate mitt romney. let's watch the point we've just made by one of the candidates. >> i think that if you combine santorum and perry and bachmann and me, and compare it to the
7:41 pm
romney numbers, it's going to be overwhelming that the conservative base of the party is still there and that governor romney remains, basically, a massachusetts moderate. and he's not -- he has not broken out, despite spending millions of dollars. and i think as we go on, through new hampshire, to south glenn and florida and beyond, those numbers will ultimately prove decisive in the race. >> jonathan, when you look around the country, this is the first test tomorrow night. this is iowa. we're going to have new hampshire next and then south carolina and then florida. at what point is somebody else going to emerge as the true blue conservative alternative to mitt romney, who everybody seems to know deep down is a moderate republican, sort of, of the old school. >> that's right.
7:42 pm
if santorum wins here tomorrow or comes close to the top, he should have a case to make for why he should be that candidate. but here's the problem. when santorum gets to south carolina in january -- >> it is january. >> the 21st of january, when the votes are cast in south carolina, he's going to find rick perry, newt gingrich, and perhaps michele bachmann. >> still there? >> all down there waiting for him. it's what joe was saying. it's math. >> south carolina will be the super bowl for the true conservative candidates that emerge. and then you're going to have after that in florida and elsewhere, you're going to have romney, you're going to have the anti-romney, and you're going to have ron paul. and romney will have to struggle to get 51% of the votes, because this thing could go on for a while. the other thing i would say is this, looking at newt gingrich, i would not want to be on a debate stage with that man this weekend. >> he's going for the kill now. >> mccain won in a plurality in 2008. he got 30-some percent in south carolina, and that's all he ultimately needed there. so i think the same thing could happen. the next big question in the next three weeks, chris, will conservatives pressure somebody to drop out of the race. will there be pressure on perry, on bachmann, on newt to make room for santorum? >> let me get tough here. suppose this goes to south carolina in a couple of weeks, mitt romney was pro-choice up in massachusetts. he's also lds, which could be a problem with some people, mormon. we don't know that yet.
7:43 pm
then we have the problem, he signed a bill which basically has funding of abortion as part of it, which nobody seemed to focus on until today, basically. all those things together, will that kill him among the evangelical south, the baptist south? he could still win south carolina, but, you know, with the others dividing their vote. the other thing is that newt could come back there. all the polls have showed him pretty strong. it's almost a home game for him. that's his advantage. >> i think a lot of freddy krueger in this guy. i think newt gingrich can come back and back and back, friday the 13th. thank you very much, joe klein. thank you, jonathan martin. up next, the invisible campaign. president obama's team has quietly slipped into iowa. president obama's here. and they've been hitting hard at mitt romney. that's ahead. this is "hardball" at java joe's in des moines. how do you pronounce that? it's french. only on msnbc.
7:44 pm
is this your normal? jamie lee curtis?? oh, hi, yes...wow, you really went all out on the decorations, huh?! yeah, but i'm so slow taking them down after all the fatty holiday food. but that's normal. what do you mean that's normal? it doesn't have to be. to me, normal, means feeling good inside. not slow. try some activia. activia helps with occasional irregularity, when eaten 3 times a day. keep a video diary and let me know about your new normal. love your new normal or it's free. uh, trouble with a car insurance claim. ah, claim trouble. [ dennis ] you should just switch to allstate, and get their new claim satisfaction guarantee. hey, he's right man. [ dennis ] only allstate puts their money where their mouth is. yup. [ dennis ] claim service so good, it's guaranteed. [ foreman ] so i can always count on them.
7:45 pm
unlike randy over there. that's one dumb dude. ♪ the new claim satisfaction guarantee. dollar for dollar, nobody protects you like allstate.
7:46 pm
real, objective investing help? that's a little harder to find. but here's what i know -- td ameritrade doesn't manage mutual funds... or underwrite stocks and bonds. or even publish their own research. so, guidance from td ameritrade isn't about their priorities.
7:47 pm
it's about mine. straightforward guidance. that's what makes td ameritrade different. ♪ [ male announcer ] trade commission-free for 60 days. plus get up to $600 when you open an account. we're back. while most of the pollsters have been on the republican candidates on the iowa caucus, there's one other candidate that has participated and he's been running a well-organized and a stealth campaign out here. president barack obama. four years ago, iowa helped he won here and now the obama team has opened eight campaign offices across the state. it's held 4,000 personal meetings with potential supporters and it's made over 300,000 telephone calls to supporters in advance of tomorrow's caucuses. joining us now are obama campaign surrogate, jen sake, who also formerly worked as the
7:48 pm
white house deputy communication director, and jeff zeleny, the great reporter from "the new york times." first, let's get an objective and then from you, jane. objectively, tell me what you can tell me about the obama campaign here tomorrow and on to the general election. >> for one thing, president obama is actually on the ballot tomorrow. democrats are going to go out to voice their support for him, so one thing they're trying to do is to make sure that that number is fairly high, and make sure there isn't any trouble in places like johnson county and iowa city to get someone else on the ballot or to nominate someone else in those precincts. the real point of the democratic caucuses is sort of a test run for organizing. i've spent a lot of time with some neighborhood volunteers and organizers from obama for america, and these people have been out here making phone calls, out trying to drum up support. you know, first for the health
7:49 pm
care initiative, then for other things. but finally they have something really to organize. so the things tomorrow night is just trying to drum up support to fire up the old gang, if you will. they have a lot of work here jen may disagree, but the obama campaign has an uphill battle here in iowa over the next ten months. >> let's respond to both those questions. to do. how good is your organization? is it aimed at warming up the line, getting it hot for next fall? and two, how big of a challenge is it to get the president -- the delegates, the electoral votes from iowa? >> it's great to be back in iowa. this is a place that has so much history for the president and he's been continuing this conversation with the people in the state since he won four years ago and had that incredible night. you can tell from the crowd here, we have a lot of obama supporters in the crowd that we love. >> actually, they're "hardball" supporters. >> that's fine. >> maybe both. >> that's fine. >> how many here for obama? [ crowd cheering ] >> there are some obama supporters here. but the most interesting thing about the next several days when the republican campaign packs up their things and leave, the obama office will still be here. this is a continuing conversation. tomorrow night's a part of that. the president will be live
7:50 pm
streaming into caucuses all across the state, having a conversation with the people. but we know that we need to talk about what needs to be done with the economy, where we're going h the economy. where we're going to leave the country. that's exactly what he'll be doing tomorrow night. >> how would you describe it as a part dan, that's what you are, fair enough, how would you describe the need to carry iowa? how important is the hawkeye state? do you need it? >> there are many paths to get there. the president loves this state. i think there's no question he wants to win it next november. >> what do you think, jeff, in terms of the importance of this state? >> he absolutely needs iowa. i can't imagine a sncenario whee the president being re-elected if he does not win the state of iowa. mathematically it's possible. if you're not winning in iowa, you're in trouble other places. i think a couple -- >> the unemployment here, by the way -- >> it's 5.7%. >> which means it's better off for him. >> it is.
7:51 pm
republicans have become more organize organiz organized here over the last four years. republicans had great victories here in 2012. governor branstad is back. you know, i mean, he's -- several republicans, so they control the house and things. it will be pretty even up. the good thing is we'll come back to iowa many times between now and next november. >> if the unemployment rate goes back up to about 9%, that's worst case scenario, how does the president make his case for re-election? if the number goes up again to the 9% which seems to awful? >> well, it is, but you know, the case is that the contrast between what the candidates are offering. you have, whether it's mitt romney or rick perry or whomever is running on the republican side or platform, they're running against a plan for the -- it's economic security of the middle class. the president is presenting a contrast to that. i would encourage anybody to go back and read the speech the president gave when he won the iowa caucuses. he promised a tax cut for middle class, end to the war in iraq. affordable, accessible health care to americans. he's done those.
7:52 pm
the journey is not done. he wants to continue that the next four years, five years. >> you're hopeful. >> absolutely. >> jeff, how do you bet this state right now? >> depends on who the nominee, of course. we're going to have a window into that, to the results of the iowa caucuses tomorrow night. if mitt romney happens to win, it will be a shorter nominating contest and romney and obama will be going after each other a lot. i think mitt romney could have some strength here. he's a middle of the road conservative, although doesn't look like it in this primary. at the end of the day iowa will be very close. >> i think he's more moderate than he's willing to admit. they do believe he's the candidate for the past month. they're holding events in iowa with randy johnston, a man who was fire the from his job in 1992 after romney's company, bain capital, took over the company where he worked. listen to how johnston characterized romney and his co-workers at bain capital in an interview with abc news just last week. >> i really believe, i think it's come out over years since
7:53 pm
this time, by other bain capital directors, that they had actually had a philosophy, a way of doing business and it was to make themselves richer. >> at the expense of? >> of the workers. i mean, they were to make the companies lean. they were going to drive up debt, charge fees, sell stock. wh whatever it takes to make big dollars for the investors. families were devastated. some cases we had the husband and wife both working there. they lost all income. and it doesn't get much worse than that. >> he makes it sound like the classic chop shop operation. go into a company, fire everybody. the company dies in a few months. you made a ton of money. >> well, look -- >> is that what bain capital is all about? >> i think mitt romney has been parading around as a big job creator but the guy was working for a company where his job was to make a profit for his investors. that's how a lot of businesses work, but let's not pretend you're out there running a -- >> mitt romney is a job killer, not a job creator. >> and a benefit cutter as well. >> thank you, jen. good luck out here.
7:54 pm
jeff, as always. great to is you from "the new york times." when we return, let me finish with dollars over democracy. you're watching "hardball" from des moines, the eve before the iowa caucuses. only on msnbc. ] to the 5:00 a.m. scholar. the two trains and a bus rider. the "i'll sleep when it's done" academic. for 80 years, we've been inspired by you. and we've been honored to walk with you to help you get where you want to be. ♪ because your moment is now. let nothing stand in your way. learn more at keller.edu.
7:55 pm
7:56 pm
7:57 pm
let me finish tonight with this. this republican caucus in iowa has the looks of a travesty. a victory of dollars over democracy, financial equity over equality.
7:58 pm
romney's destroying the only opponent he fears for the nomination with a relentless wealth-driven advertising campaign the voter can only escape if he turns off his television set. without his fingerprints on the ads or face or name attached to it. he's standing before crowds reciting verses from "america the beautiful." if there's ever been a more cynical use of money and media, it's hard to recall. . tuesday night's results, will it mean iowa likes romney or that voters of iowa have been used to destroy his most formidable opponent? what it looks like iowa will say, what it likes often, likes the candidate who adheres most closely to the evangelical line. they have a perfect vessel. rick santorum of pennsylvania is pro life, educates his children at home, opposed to same-sex marriage. he's to the evangelicals and christian conservatives one of them. ron paul will also get his share
7:59 pm
of the vote tomorrow. the libertarian both. bolstered by the young and anti-war of all ages. you may have noticed no republican has whispered the name w. in this campaign. try and find republicans who are ready to stand up and say the iraq war made sense or wants the decider as he called himself out there working the rope line for him. no, this am campaign fits a groove. the conservatives looking for someone who thinks like them and could still beat obama, they've seen their hope killed by an extensive stealth campaign that's left them with a choice of voting for mitt romney. i bet they flinch from that. they'll hold back in ways to avoid voting for someone they know in their souls is not one of them. if mitt romney breaks 25% of the vote tomorrow night it will be a victory of stealth over openness, cynicism over conviction and as i said, financial equity over equality of voters and dollars over
left
right